Really, the myth that the Court somehow stole the election is getting up there with 9/11 Trutherism and Kennedy conspiracy theories. Tim Carney, commenting on a Dana Milbank article in The Washington Post that claims the Court denied Joe Lieberman the vice-presidency, sets the record straight:
But the Supreme Court didn’t deny Lieberman Florida. The voters of Florida did.
How do I know?
Because of the media recounts after the election.
If SCOTUS had never taken up the case, or had let the Florida Supreme Court ruing stand, we would have had a statewide recount of all undervotes — and Bush would have won, according to the media recounts.
If Gore had gotten what he was asking for, a hand recount in four counties, Bush still would have won, according to the media recounts.
Some liberals hang their hat on a third, imaginary recount of all ballots, including overvotes. About that imaginary recount (1) it would have been illegal, (2) Gore probably would have opposed it, and (3) which no court had ordered. And even so, only maybe would it have given the election to Gore.
Really, people. Get over it. Gore lost, and he lost because he couldn’t carry even his home state.